NATIONAL
ORGANIZATION of CIRCUMCISION
INFORMATION RESOURCE CENTERS
P.O. Box 2512 San Anselmo, California 94960 Telephone: (415) 488-9883
FLORIDA BABY SWITCH ANOTHER REASON NOT TO CIRCUMCISE
"KEEP NEWBORN CLOSE TO YOU," HEALTH GROUP ADVISES
--How Safe are Your Area Hospitals?--
SAN ANSELMO, CA. -- The switch of two babies at a
Florida Maternity hospital gives "tragic new meaning" to
the American Academy of Pediatrics' position that
circumcision has "inherent disadvantages and risks," a
non-profit California health group said this week.
"When a mother for any reason lets a newborn baby
out of her eyesight at a maternity hospital, there is
always a risk of mixup or abduction," said Marilyn Fayre
Milos, R.N., executive director of NOCIRC. "The painful,
unnecessary practice of circumcision is clearly not
worth that risk."
Milos cited the Florida mixup of two girls and the
abduction of an infant boy at a Maryland hospital as the
"tip of an iceberg which may be bigger than we think."
"The Maryland mother was not concerned by her
newborn's absence from her room because she had been
told he would be taken away for a circumcision," Milos
said. "Instead he was kidnapped."
"In a hospital, don't let your babies out of your
sight," Nurse Milos warned expectant parents, "unless
some extreme medical need requires it. There is no
health reason to circumcise, but if you really must, as
painful as it will be for your and your son, insist on
your right to be there."
This year the American Academy of Pediatrics
reaffirmed that newborn circumcision has "inherent
disadvantages and risks" and the practice is in decline
among the educated, with 40% of U.S. male babies now
left intact (non-circumcised). Circumcision is no longer
practiced outside the U.S., except religously.
"Besides the pain and risk of circumcision," Milos
said, "removing an infant from his mother's room
increases the chance of mixup and abduction."
Milos said that there is growing belief among
health professionals that babies should be kept close to
their mothers in the early days -- as opposed to
"wharehousing" in hospital nurseries -- and that the
infliction of pain on newborns through harsh lights,
noise, and genital surgery was "cruel and unnecessary."
11/25/89
Return to the NOCIRC home page |